8 min read

5 Tips for Conducting Effective Reference Checks

Conducting effective reference checks can help you identify red flags or potential issues that may not have been apparent during the interview process. This can help you avoid hiring candidates who may not be a good fit for the role or the company culture.

‍

Key Takeaways

Start reference checks early to avoid delays in hiring.
Use a set list of questions to keep the process fair for all candidates.
Verify information using both professional personal references and former managers.
Take detailed notes to help you compare candidates later.
Look for what a reference does not say as much as what they do say.

Hiring a new employee is a big step for any business. You spend hours reading resumes and meeting people in interviews. However, what you see on paper or in a meeting is only part of the story. To make informed hiring decisions, you need to know how a person acts when they are actually at work. This is where the reference check comes in.

Conducting reference checks is a way to verify that the person you want to hire is who they say they are. It helps you see if their skills match the needs of your company. Many people find this part of hiring to be a chore. They might skip it or only do a quick phone call. If you want to build a strong team, you must take this step seriously. By following these effective reference checks tips, you can find the right fit for your team and avoid costly mistakes.

The Value of the Reference Checking Process

The reference checking process is your final safety net. It allows you to talk to people who have seen the candidate work in real situations. An interview can tell you if someone is good at talking. A reference check tells you if they are good at doing.

When you call a reference, you are looking for more than just a confirmation of dates. You want to understand the person's work habits. You want to know how they handle stress. You also want to see if they get along with others. This information is hard to get from an interview alone. Using these steps helps you make sure your choice is based on facts rather than just a good feeling.

Tip 1: Start the Process Early

One of the best effective reference checks tips is to begin as soon as you can. Do not wait until the very last minute to ask for references. If you wait until you are ready to send a job offer, you might feel rushed. Rushing can lead to mistakes.

Get Consent and Contact Info

Ask your candidates for their list of references during the middle of the hiring cycle. Make sure you have their written permission to contact these people. This keeps you safe from legal trouble and shows the candidate that you are thorough.

Set Expectations with the Candidate

Tell the candidate that you will be calling their references soon. This gives them a chance to reach out to their references first. When a reference knows a call is coming, they are more likely to answer the phone. They will also have time to think about the candidate's work history. This leads to better conversations for you.

Avoid Hiring Delays

If you start early, you can finish your checks by the time you finish final interviews. This helps you move fast when you find a great person. In a competitive market, speed is very helpful. You do not want to lose a great candidate because you took too long to call their old boss.

Tip 2: Use a Standard List of Questions

To make the best choice, you must be fair. The best way to be fair is to use a standard list of questions for every reference. This allows you to compare the answers for different candidates easily.

Focus on Behavior

Ask questions that require more than a "yes" or "no" answer. You want the reference to tell you stories. For example, instead of asking if the person is a hard worker, ask them to describe a time the person went above and beyond.

Verify Technical Skills

You should ask about the specific tasks the person will do in the new role. If the job requires data entry, ask the reference about the candidate's speed and accuracy. You can also use other tools like skill assessments to check their talent, but a reference can tell you how they use those skills in a real office.

Sample Questions to Include:

What were the candidate's main duties?
How would you describe their work style?
Can you give an example of how they handled a difficult project?
What is one area where they could improve?
Would you hire this person again?

Using the same questions for everyone makes your reference checking process more professional. It helps you stay focused on the facts that matter for the job.

Tip 3: Speak with Multiple Reference Types

A single reference only gives you one point of view. To get the full picture, you should talk to different types of people. This includes both professional personal references and direct supervisors.

Former Managers

A former boss is the most important reference. They can tell you about the person's performance and if they met their goals. They also know if the person followed company rules and showed up on time.

Peers and Coworkers

Coworkers see a different side of a person. They know if the candidate is helpful or if they are hard to work with on a team. Talking to a peer can tell you a lot about the candidate's social skills and how they handle daily tasks.

Professional Personal References

Sometimes a candidate might provide professional personal references. These are people like mentors, clients, or partners who know the person in a work context but did not manage them. These people can speak to the candidate's character and growth over time. Having a mix of these sources helps you see the candidate from all angles.

Tip 4: Document All Responses Carefully

When you are busy hiring, it is easy to forget what a reference said. You might talk to three different references for two different people in one day. Without notes, the details will get blurry.

Write as You Listen

Take notes during the phone call. Do not try to remember everything and write it down later. Write down the specific words the reference uses. If they say a candidate is "fine," that is different from saying they are "excellent."

Keep a Record for the File

Keep these notes in the candidate's file. This is important for your records. If anyone asks why you hired one person over another, you have the proof. It shows that you made your decision based on the facts you gathered.

Look for Patterns

After you finish all the calls for a candidate, read your notes. Look for things that match. If three different people say the candidate is great at solving problems, you can trust that it is true. If one person says they are great but another says they struggle, you might need to ask more questions.

Tip 5: Listen for Red Flags and Hesitation

Sometimes what a person does not say is just as important as what they do say. You must listen carefully to the tone of the reference's voice.

Watch for Long Pauses

If you ask a simple question and the reference stays quiet for a long time, they might be trying to think of a way to avoid saying something bad. This is a sign that there might be an issue.

Check for Inconsistencies

Compare what the reference says to what the candidate said in their interview. If the candidate said they managed a team of ten, but the reference says they only managed two, that is a red flag. It means the candidate might not be telling the truth.

Follow Up on Vague Answers

If a reference gives a very short or vague answer, do not be afraid to ask for more detail. Ask for an example. If they cannot give one, they might not know the candidate's work as well as they claim. Or, they might be hiding a problem.

Common Challenges in Reference Checking

Conducting reference checks is not always easy. You will run into problems from time to time. Knowing how to handle them will help you stay on track.

Unresponsive References

Sometimes a reference will not call you back. This can be frustrating. If this happens, ask the candidate to provide a new reference. You can also ask the candidate to reach out to the reference and ask them to call you. If a candidate cannot get anyone to speak for them, that is a bad sign.

Company Policy Limits

Some big companies have rules that prevent managers from giving detailed references. They might only confirm the person's job title and the dates they worked there. If you hit this wall, try to find other references who might be able to speak more freely, such as former coworkers who have also left that company.

Biased References

Every now and then, a reference might be a close friend of the candidate. They might only say nice things. This is why it is important to ask for specific examples of work. It is hard to fake a detailed story about a work project.

Legal and Ethical Considerations

You must follow the law when you check references. This protects your business and the people you are calling.

Stay Away from Personal Questions

Only ask about work. Do not ask about a person's religion, age, health, or family life. These questions are often illegal and can lead to lawsuits. Stick to the job duties and work performance.

Keep Information Private

The information you get from a reference is private. Do not share it with people who are not part of the hiring team. Make sure your notes are stored in a safe place.

Be Honest with the Reference

Tell the reference who you are and why you are calling. Be clear about the job the candidate is applying for. This helps the reference give you the most useful information.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many references should I check?‍

It is standard to check at least three references. This usually includes two former managers and one peer or professional contact.

Can I check references that are not on the candidate's list?

‍In many places, it is better to stick to the list provided by the candidate. If you want to talk to someone else, it is a good idea to ask the candidate for permission first. This maintains trust.

What if a reference gives a bad review?

‍Do not count a candidate out based on one bad comment. Look for patterns. If one person is negative but everyone else is positive, the issue might be with the reference rather than the candidate. However, if multiple people mention the same problem, you should take it seriously.

Is it okay to do reference checks by email?

‍Phone calls are usually better because you can hear the person's tone of voice. However, email can work if the reference is very busy or lives in a different time zone.

Should I check references before or after the interview?

‍Most people check references after the final interview. This saves you time because you only check the people you are seriously considering for the job.

Strengthening Your Hiring Choices

Making a hire is a risk. You are putting your time and money into a new person. Using these effective reference checks tips helps lower that risk. When you take the time to prepare, ask the right questions, and listen closely, you gain a clear view of the person you are hiring.

A good reference checking process does more than just spot bad candidates. It also helps you understand how to manage your new hire. If a reference tells you that a candidate works best with clear deadlines, you can use that information to help them succeed from day one.

Do not view this part of hiring as a simple box to check. View it as a chance to learn. The more you know before someone starts, the better your team will be. By being thorough and fair, you make sure that every new person you bring on is a step toward a better business. Use these tips to build a team that is strong, honest, and ready to work.